"Food grade" and "FDA-approved" are phrases used in purchase orders every day, and neither is a regulatory status. The FDA does not approve materials; it maintains lists of substances that may be used in food-contact articles, and the compliance of a finished seal depends on the whole recipe, the curing process, and the extraction testing — not on the polymer's name.
This note sets out what the main frameworks actually require, so a specification can be written that a supplier can meet and an auditor can check.

The US framework: 21 CFR 177.2600
Rubber articles intended for repeated use in contact with food are covered by 21 CFR 177.2600. The regulation has three parts that matter to a seal:
- The ingredients must be listed. Every substance in the compound — polymer, filler, plasticiser, curing agent, antioxidant, pigment — has to be either generally recognised as safe, prior-sanctioned, or listed in the regulation with its conditions of use.
- Extraction limits apply. The finished article is extracted with distilled water and with n-hexane under specified conditions, and the residue must not exceed the limits in the regulation.
- The article must be suitable for repeated use. Single-use food contact is a different set of rules.
The practical consequence: two FKM compounds, both made from listed ingredients, can differ in compliance because one uses a curing system that leaves a residue above the extraction limit. Compliance is a property of the recipe and the cure, not of the base polymer.
The EU framework
Food contact in the EU is governed by Framework Regulation 1935/2004, which requires that materials do not transfer constituents in quantities that endanger health or change the food's composition and taste. Specific measures exist for plastics (10/2011) and for some other materials; rubber is covered by national rules in most member states, with the German BfR Recommendation XXI being the most widely referenced.
In practice, an EU-compliant seal is usually supported by:
- A declaration of compliance (DoC) referencing 1935/2004 and the applicable national measure.
- Migration testing to the food simulants relevant to the application — aqueous, acidic, fatty, alcoholic.
- A statement of the test conditions (time and temperature), because migration results are only valid for the conditions tested.
Drinking water: three schemes, one logic
Drinking water contact is regulated separately from food contact, and the approvals are national or regional:
| Scheme | Market | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| NSF/ANSI 61 | US and Canada | Components in contact with drinking water; extraction testing plus formulation review |
| WRAS | UK | Water fittings and materials; mechanical and leachable requirements |
| KTW | Germany | Elastomer components in drinking water contact |
| ACS | France | Same logic, French scheme |
All four work the same way: the formulation is reviewed against a positive list, and the finished part is tested for leachables under defined exposure conditions. A seal certified to one scheme is not automatically accepted in another market — the tests and the lists differ.
Hygiene design: 3-A and EHEDG
For dairy, beverage and pharmaceutical processing, the design of the seal and the groove matters as much as the compound. 3-A Sanitary Standards and EHEDG guidelines require:
- No crevices where product can accumulate and bacteria can grow.
- Cleanability, verified by a defined cleaning procedure.
- Materials that withstand the cleaning and sanitising chemicals, not only the product.
This is where the wrong answer is often chosen: a compound fully compliant with food-contact regulations can still fail a hygiene design review because the groove traps product, or because the seal swells in the caustic cleaning cycle while being perfectly resistant to the food itself.
Why "FDA-approved" is the wrong phrase
The FDA approves drugs and devices. For food-contact materials it maintains regulations that define what may be used and how much may migrate. A supplier who says "FDA-approved" is either simplifying or misstating; the accurate statement is "the compound is formulated to meet 21 CFR 177.2600" or "a declaration of compliance is available".
That distinction matters because an auditor or a customer's QA will ask for the declaration, not for a logo. The document set that actually satisfies them is:
- A declaration of compliance naming the regulation and the compound.
- The extraction or migration test report, with conditions.
- A statement of the maximum use temperature, because migration increases with temperature and the compliance is temperature-dependent.
- A change-control statement: what happens to the declaration if the recipe changes.
Which regulation? Which test conditions? What is the declared maximum temperature? What happens to the declaration when the recipe changes?
Where seals fail compliance in practice
- The seal is compliant, the lubricant is not. Assembly grease in a food-contact joint has to be food-contact approved too. This is the most common gap.
- The seal is compliant at 100 °C and runs at 140 °C. Migration limits are declared for a temperature; above it, the declaration no longer applies.
- The compound changed. A supplier substitutes a cure system or a filler for cost or availability, and the declaration is not re-issued.
- Cleaning chemicals were not considered. A seal resistant to the product but attacked by the caustic or acid cleaning cycle fails within weeks, and the failure is blamed on the material's "food grade".
- The wrong scheme for the market. A part certified to NSF/ANSI 61 shipped into an EU drinking water project is not automatically acceptable without a WRAS or KTW equivalent.
Specifying food and water contact properly
A specification that a supplier can meet and an auditor can verify has four elements:
- The regulation, by number, and the market it applies to.
- The contact conditions: continuous or repeated, maximum temperature, and the cleaning regime.
- The documentation set required at delivery: declaration of compliance, test report, material certificate.
- The change-control requirement: notification and re-qualification if the recipe changes.
Written this way, the requirement is a document set rather than an adjective, and it survives an audit.
Frequently asked questions
What does "food grade" mean for an O-ring?
Usually that the compound is formulated to meet a food-contact regulation such as 21 CFR 177.2600, and that a declaration of compliance is available. The phrase itself has no legal definition, so ask which regulation and which test conditions.
Is silicone food safe?
Silicone is widely used in food contact because it is inert and available in compliant grades, but compliance still depends on the specific recipe and cure. A silicone compound with a non-compliant pigment or cure system is not food contact compliant.
Does NSF/ANSI 61 cover food contact?
No. NSF/ANSI 61 covers components in contact with drinking water. Food contact is a separate framework (21 CFR 177.2600 in the US, 1935/2004 in the EU).
Can a seal be food contact compliant and still fail in service?
Yes, easily. Compliance says nothing about resistance to cleaning chemicals, steam sterilisation cycles, or the mechanical duty. A compliant seal that swells in caustic cleaning solution fails in weeks.
What documentation should I ask for?
A declaration of compliance naming the regulation, the migration or extraction test report with its conditions, the declared maximum service temperature, and a statement of the change-control arrangement for the recipe.